Tuesday, December 27, 2011

2011 Year End Sumo Power Rankings

2011 Year End Sumo Power Rankings

Another year is in the books, sumo-wise, and what a year it was: more scandals, the March tournament was cancelled (hence the x in the ratings), the May tournament was reclassified as a "technical examination", yet more scandals, one ozeki mercifully retired and two rikishi with questionable credentials were promoted to ozeki. Sumo fever -- catch it.

The one positive constant this year has been, once again, Hakuho. He's so dominant that I've invented a new word to describe him. Hakuho is the "transcender", the one who transcends. I've used somewhat more prosaic descriptions for the remainder of the rikishi. Without further ado, here is the power rating list for 2011.

Average                                1/11        x     5/11   7/11   9/11   11/11

            The Transcender

128  Hakuho                        150         x      121     108     118     145    

            The Contenders (Close to the Top)

105  Kotoshogiku               101        x        87     131     111      95    

98  Baruto                             83         x        90       96        99    120
95  Harumafuji                     65         x      109    142        73      85    

94  Kakuryu                           86         x      113    102        81      86                

92 Kisenosato                       84         x        81    108       101     85    

            The Pretenders (Not Quite There)

72  Kotooshu                      95           x        29**87         6**  70       

68  Goeido                          64           x      103    41       46       85

65  Okinoumi                     38           x        77     77       76       58      

64  Toyonoshima              63           x        33     75       58       89      

            The Defenders (Middle Class)
54  Homasho                      67          x       40       42       95       25

49  Tochiozan                     56          x       45       34       60       32** 

            The Upenders -- Occasionally (Blue Collar Workers or Shirkers)

42  Takekaze                      30         x      59       47       36       37      

41  Yoshikaze                     24         x      46       49       58       28                              

40  Tochinoshin                 20         x      71       47       49       11      
39  Tochinowaka             [12]        x      18       24       30       64      

39  Aran                              52         x       46       47      24      25
37  Kitataiki                       32          x       33       18      35      38      

36  Myogiryu                     --           x        --       [11]   [13]     36      
35  Aminishiki                   51          x       43       10      29      41      

35  Shohozan                    --            x        --         [7]   [11]     35      
35  Wakakoyu                   28          x       29        54     20      44      

32  Wakanosato               30          x       37        48      39        6**              
32  Aioyama                     [[4]]        x      [[5]]       [7]   [10]**32                                          

31  Kyokutenho               26          x        29         18     42      38      

30  Miyabiyama               19         x        21         32      28      51      

            The Rear Enders (The Lower Rung)

26  Gagamaru                     18         x        24       19      57      12      

26  Tamawashi                   50         x        30       19      20      12                  

25  Toyohibiki                     26         x        29       23      19      30                              

25  Takayasu                       [9]         x        [8]       24      24      28                                          

24  Daido                              [9]         x        [8]       17      25      30                                          

24  Fujiazuma                      [8]         x        [9]       26      20      27                                          

24  Shotenro                       26       x          17         24      30      **      

            The Descenders (Demotions Waiting to Happen)
24  Tokitenku                     22         x         24        30       22      20                  

23  Kaisei                             [8]        x         29        32       15      16  
                                        
22  Sadanofuji                    [6]         x         [5]       [9]        [8]    22                                            

20  Sagatsukasa                [[5]]       x       [13]       25       19      16 
                             
20  Asasekiryu                   25          x         23        20       17      15      

Friday, December 23, 2011

The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly (Kyushu 2011 edition)

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (Kyushu 2011)

My previous blog dealt with the rikishi who had the best performances power ranking-wise at Kyushu. This blog looks at the rikishi who turned in good (forward moving) sumo, bad (henka) sumo, and ugly (non-forward moving sumo) .

The rikish who produced the best forward moving sumo totals at Kyushu are:

The Good
42 Hakuho (14-1)
36 Kotoshogiku (11-4)
35 Kotooshu (9-6)
34 Baruto (11-4)
33 Kisenosato (10-5)
33 Myogiru (10-5)


The Bad

The bad rikishi are those who were guilty of multiple henkas. All of these rikishi deserve a lump of coal in their stockings this holiday season:
7  Tokitenku
5  Kimurayama

4  Kyokutenho
4  Takekaze
4  Yoshikaze


3  Aminishiki
3  Aran
3  Sagatsukasa


2  Daido
2  Kokkai
2  Miyabiyama
2  Sadanofuji


Any way you slice it, Tokitenku’s seven henkas was a lot. Kimurayama and Takekaze’s sumo looked especially bad too. The only real surprise on this list is Miyabiyama, who appears to have added the henka to his diet (clearly his only diet, I might add) of push down and slap down sumo.  

The Ugly

I accept that for some rikishi non-forward moving sumo makes sense from time to time. However, if you score below double digits on my system you are simply stinking up the joint. The names on this list should come as no surprise:
-1  Kimurayama

For the first time doing this we have a minus score (for a rikishi who didn’t withdraw with an injury). That’s not easy to do. If I wrestled and simply moved forward at the tachi-ai for 15 days I’d end up being thrown off the dohyo 15 times and produce (presumably) a score of 0. Or, to put that score in perspective, I’d have one more point than Kimurayama ended up with at Kyushu. That truly is shocking. I hope Kimurayama never emerges from Juryo again.
5  Kokkai

7  Tokitenku
7  Kyokutenho

7  Aran

Kokkai was clearly injured (although he isn’t any good even when healthy). Kyokutenho was ranked too high; at 35 he can’t compete with the big dogs any longer, but should be fine lower down in the rankings. Tokitenku and Aran display poor form and cynical sumo tournament after tournament and it’s a crying shame.

Kyushu 2011 Best

The Power Ranking system reveals the top 11 performances in terms of strength of opponents defeated for Kyushu. Why 11? Because, to quote Nigel Tufnel, “Well, it’s one louder, isn’t it? It’s not ten.” Or maybe it’s because I care ten percent more: you decide.

                         Strength                                    W-L          Previous
     Rikishi             W-L          Win %                   Record     Ranking

1.   Hakuho              145-17          89.5%                        14-1               (1)

2.   Baruto                120-27          81.6%                        11-4               (4)

3.   Kotoshogiku        95-58           62.0%                        11-4              (2)

4.   Toyonoshima      89-74           54.6%                          9-6               (10)

5.   Kakuryu                86-79           52.1%                        10-5              (6)

6.   Kisenosato           85-80           51.5%                        10-5              (3)  

6.   Harumafuji          85-79           51.8%                          8-7               (8)

6.   Goeido                 85-83           50.5%                          7-8               (NR)  

9.   Kotooshu             70-84           45.4%                          9-6               (NR)  

10. Tochinowaka      64-97           39.7%                          7-8               (NR)

11. Okinoumi            58-115         33.5%                          7-8               (7)


There really aren’t a lot of comments needed. No one is close to Hakuho. Although Baruto and Kotoshogiku finished with the same won-loss record it makes a huge difference if you are beating the bottom end of the jo’i or the top end of the sanyaku.

There is basically a four-way tie for 5 through 8 (and a three way tie for most wins at 6). I guess the basic comment here is that Kisenosato did not turn in a performance worthy of ozeki promotion, but that’s beating a dead horse at this point.

The big break in the rankings occurs at 9, Kotooshu, as he beat the bottom dwellers (or, to use the oft employed phrase, “rank and filers”) and lost to most of the good rikishi. His win on day 15 over Harumafuji was necessary for him to have a winning record for the year: 32-31-12. It must be ozeki pride that helped him pull that one out.
Tochinowaka makes this list for the first time. Get used to it, because the kid is good.

Henka Count in Kyushu 2011

Henka Count in Kyushu 2011
Total   Rikishi                        Day(s) in Which the Henka Occurred

7          Tokitenku                 4, 6, 7, 9, 10, 13, 14

5          Kimurayama            2, 4, 5, 12, 15

4          Kyokutenho             6, 7, 8, 9

            Takekaze                  2, 4, 8, 13

            Yoshikaze                 7, 10, 14, 15

3          Aminishiki                2, 7, 13

            Aran                          4, 12, 13

            Sagatsukasa            5, 12, 15

2          Daido                       4, 5

            Kokkai                      9, 11

            Miyabiyama            11, 12

            Sadanofuji               5, 6

1          Asasekiryu              3

            Fujiazauma             11

            Myogiryu                 6

            Tochinoshin            12